Call Now 902-678-2121

Home Veins Comparing treatments

EVLT, adhesive closure, surgeryCompared honestly.

There is more than one good way to close a diseased vein. Here is an honest comparison from a vascular surgeon.

We offer endovenous laser treatment and sclerotherapy, and our surgeons perform and refer for vein surgery. We do not offer adhesive closure. Rather than talk around that, this page sets the options side by side and is clear about which cells we cannot fill in.

Comparison

The options side by side

Only what this site already publishes is stated as fact. Everything else is a question for our surgeon, shown in place.

What you are comparing EVLT (laser) VenaSeal (adhesive) Ligation & stripping Sclerotherapy (foam)
How it works A laser fibre is placed inside the vein. The heat causes the blood and vein wall to coagulate, and the vein shrinks and eventually fibroses. The vein is closed from the inside. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — how would you describe adhesive closure to a patient, in one sentence?]
The vein is physically removed through incisions. An agent is injected into the vein through a needle, making it shrink and disappear. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — our sclerotherapy is liquid. Do you want foam described separately here?]
Anesthesia Local anesthetic only. No general anesthetic and no sedation. A topical anesthetic goes on 30 to 45 minutes beforehand. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — what anesthesia does adhesive closure require?]
General anesthetic. None.
Setting In our office. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — office or hospital?]
Hospital operating room. In our office.
Typical procedure time About one to two hours in total. The laser itself takes minutes; the preparation, ultrasound and tumescence take the rest. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — typical procedure time?]
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — typical procedure time for ligation and stripping?] [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — typical time for a sclerotherapy session?]
Compression stockings after [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — do EVLT patients wear compression afterward, and for how long? The site does not say] Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — is compression used after adhesive closure?]
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — compression after stripping surgery?] Fourteen days. This is part of what makes the treatment work rather than an optional extra.
Return to normal activity Most patients walk out and resume normal daily activities immediately. You walk for 30 minutes before getting into a car. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — expected return to activity?]
A recovery measured in weeks. Avoid exercise, hot baths and alcohol for two to three days.
Long-term evidence base Studies show endovenous laser treatment is more effective than ligation and stripping, with significantly less pain and a shorter recovery. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — approve the citations: NICE CG168, and Rasmussen LH et al., Br J Surg 2011] Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — how would you characterise the published evidence, without making claims about any clinic's results?]
The comparison above is the one the published studies make. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — how would you characterise the evidence for foam sclerotherapy?]
Typical cost range in Canada We have found no Canadian health insurance companies that cover the cost of this procedure, and we provide information to help you make a coverage request. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — may we publish a price range?] Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — do you want a cost range published for comparison?]
Covered financially by provincial health plans. Private and public payment options are available depending on your situation. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — may we publish a price range?]
Best suited for Larger refluxing veins, typically a refluxing saphenous vein found on ultrasound. Not offered at Valley Medical.
[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — which patients is adhesive closure best suited to?]
Many patients have the option of surgery, and Dr Davidson can discuss whether it applies to you. [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — when do you still recommend surgery?] Spider veins, reticular veins and smaller surface veins. Needs a vessel big enough for the needle.

We do not offer adhesive closure, so the cells in that column are questions for our surgeon rather than claims about anyone else's results.

In our surgeon's words

Why we chose EVLT

A clinic that only offers one thing has an obvious incentive to tell you it is best. Here is our reasoning, in the open.

[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — a short quote on why the clinic uses EVLT: your experience with it since 2007, what the evidence base means to you, and how it fits the one-visit model]
Dr Dion DavidsonVascular surgeon, Valley Medical

What we can say without waiting for anyone: this clinic has been treating veins in Nova Scotia since 2007, endovenous laser has been our main tool for closing refluxing veins over that time, and the one-visit model was built around it. The scan and the surgeon consultation happen in the same appointment, and treatment follows from what the scan shows rather than from what we happen to own.

Start here

The question that matters more than the tool

Which device closes your vein matters less than which vein is failing.

Most comparisons of vein treatments are really comparisons of devices. That is the wrong starting point for a patient.

The treatments are not interchangeable. Endovenous laser closes a refluxing saphenous vein. Patients without refluxing saphenous veins need a different treatment, and no device changes that. Spider veins and fine surface veins are a different problem again.

So the question that decides your treatment is not which tool a clinic owns. It is which of your veins is failing, how far it extends, and what that means for your symptoms. A duplex ultrasound answers that in about the time it takes to read this page, and at our clinic a vascular surgeon reads it back to you in the same visit.

Start with the scan

A painless scan maps the veins in your legs and shows how blood is actually moving through them. Everything else follows from it.

About the ultrasound assessment

Comparing treatments, answered

Questions

The questions patients ask when they are weighing their options.

Is VenaSeal better than laser?

We do not offer adhesive closure, so we are not the right people to make that claim, and we will not make claims about another clinic's results. What we can tell you is why we use endovenous laser: [CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — one or two sentences on why EVLT, for a patient weighing the options] The more useful question is usually not which device, but whether the vein causing your symptoms is one that should be closed at all. That is what the ultrasound answers.

Do I need compression stockings after EVLT?

[CLIENT TO CONFIRM: Dr Davidson — do EVLT patients wear compression afterward, and for how long?] After sclerotherapy, compression is worn for fourteen days, and after elōs™ laser it is not needed at all.

Is vein stripping still done?

Yes. Many patients have the option of surgery, which is covered financially by provincial health plans, and your surgeon can discuss whether it applies to you. What has changed is that it is no longer the only option: studies show endovenous laser treatment is more effective, with significantly less pain and a shorter recovery.

Which is covered by insurance?

Ligation and stripping surgery is covered financially by provincial health plans. For endovenous laser treatment, we have found no Canadian health insurance companies that cover the cost, and we provide information to help you make a coverage request. Sclerotherapy has both private and public payment options depending on your situation. What applies to you depends on the clinical picture, which is what the assessment establishes.

Why does the ultrasound matter more than the device?

Because the treatments are not interchangeable. Patients without refluxing saphenous veins need a different treatment, and no device changes that. The scan tells you which vein is the problem, and that decides what should be done about it.

Read next

Related

More detail on the treatments we provide.

How EVLT works, the procedure day, recovery and the full FAQ.

For spider and reticular veins, with compression for fourteen days afterward.

The practical differences between closing a vein and removing it.

Get an ultrasound and a surgeon's opinion in one visit.

You will leave knowing which vein is causing your symptoms and what the options are, including the ones we do not provide ourselves.

Be the first to know.

Get advance notice of all promotions, contests and special events we hold, direct to your inbox.